Learning more...

I have been interviewing one of the occupational therapists who worked with some of my women while they were adjusting to their new life as an amputee.  It has been very interesting because several of the women remembered that they had made a quick decision soon after they were injured to accept their loss and move on.  Yet, someone who helped them through the process of adaptation felt that they did go through a grief process though it was much shorter than it was for others.  I think it must be something like giving birth to a child.  If you remembered how painful it was, every mother would only have one child.


The staff that worked with soldiers who had become seriously injured, including those who lost limbs, used Kubler & Ross's Stage Theory of grieving as a template.  I am interested in learning more about how they felt that template worked.  In my 11 years of working with individuals and families who were seriously injured or who had lost a loved one, I found that grieving was more like a ball of yarn.  Within a day or even a few hours it was possible to feel all the different stages of grief:  denial, anger, acceptance, bargaining, depression...all tangled up.  This therapist also noted that men were more likely to show anger while women were more likely to be depressed.  Not surpressing considering our culture and feelings that are considered acceptable for men and for women.

Executive Summary

A Phenomenological Study of Female Military

Servicemembers' Adjustment to Traumatic Amputation

Executive Summary

         Over 220,000 women have served in Iraq (OIF) and Afghanistan (OEF) (Alvarez, 2009), many with multiple deployments. Women are actively participating in many combat operations and sustaining traumatic injuries as a result.  These injuries included traumatic amputation, yet there is no published research on the psychosocial adaptation of servicewomen to this phenomenon.

         This phenomenological study sought to increase our understanding of the psychosocial adjustment issues women experienced after a traumatic amputation.  A search of the research literature did not retrieve any articles that specifically addressed the adaptation of women below the age of 55 to amputation. Research indicated that current issues for military women were military sexual trauma, PTSD, and deployment adjustment issues.  Research indicated the issues for women amputees were adjustment to a new body image, adjustment to prosthetics, and psychosocial adjustment to amputation. Limited current research indicated that women were less likely to be employed after an amputation and had more difficulties with self-care tasks. 

Six Army/Army National Guard women were interviewed in this study: three enlisted and three officers. At the time of the study, their ages ranged from 24 to 42; three were married and three were single; the lowest rank was Specialist and the highest was Major; five were injured in combat and one completed a tour of duty in Iraq on a prosthetic leg. Their injuries ranged from the loss of a lower limb, to the loss of one to two arms, or the loss of both legs.

         Each participant was asked three questions; (1) Please describe your experience in combat as a woman.  (2) In what ways, if any, has being injured changed your life?  (3) If you were to visit a woman in the hospital with your same injuries who was just beginning her journey to recover, what would you tell her? All of the women in this study had a positive experience in the Army and felt that in their unit they were treated the same as the male soldiers.   After losing one or more limbs they had to cope with both physical and psychosocial adjustments. The physical adjustment issues included loss of functionality/mobility, adjustment to a prosthetic device, adaptation to the loss of one or more arms without a prosthetic device, phantom pain, pain from prosthetic usage, and pain from posture issues due to the loss of an arm creating an unbalanced upper body. Sweating due to the loss of body mass was also an issue for some women. The two women who lost both legs also struggled with balance issues, particularly when trying to carry something.

         The psychosocial adjustment issues included adjustment to a new body image, personal safety fears, grief and loss, and adjustment to the attitudes of strangers to a woman amputee. Participants' adjustment to amputation was eased by maintaining a positive attitude; believing that their loss served a greater purpose; receiving social support from family, friends and other wounded warriors; maintaining a personal sense humor; realizing it could have been worse; and recovering in a military culture with the values of personal courage, mission focus and never give up.

         The advice these women would give to another woman just beginning the journey of adjustment to amputation was: maintain a positive attitude, seek out the social support of friends and family, and use humor to help others adjust to your changed body image.  These women would also say: life will return to normal and you will be able to do most everything you did before, but you may have to do it differently.  While two of the women stated that their positive attitude was a personality trait, military training also helped instill positivism. All three of the married women benefitted from having their spouse by their side during all or most of their recovery.  These women reported that during their recovery they were supported by family, friends, other wounded warriors and military comrades.  Amy said, “Surrounding yourself with family and friends, your support system, is huge.”  Lisa and Amy’s father noted that wounded warriors without strong social support were more likely to become depressed and give up.

Most of the women used humor to help put others at ease.  Lisa, who lost both arms above the elbow, used humor to help friends, family and strangers feel more comfortable in her presence. Two of the women in this study still serve in the National Guard, and one has applied to Army helicopter pilot school. Two are employed: One is a public relations executive, and another is CEO of a consulting company that hires many wounded warriors. Another is completing her internship to become a prosthetist, and three are planning to attend college.

         Losing a limb is life changing.  The process of adjustment requires an individual to first physically adapt to the injury and then complete physical and occupational therapy to regain mobility and/or functionality. They must also cope with the attitudes of others.  The near death experience of severe combat injury gave several of these women courage to explore new opportunities: Christine ran for political office and then became a public relations executive; Amy competed in the Paralympics, is a professional speaker, and is finishing her training to become a prosthetist; Sarah established a company that now has over one hundred employees; and Jessica volunteered for a tour in Iraq as an amputee. Amy said that she has “made more of her life with one leg than she ever would have with two.” Without the experience of becoming a combat amputee, three of these women probably would not have had the opportunities that led to new careers. While three women plan to pursue new careers through higher education, only one has yet to act on that plan. Yet, when you consider that she was in a coma for four weeks, and her physicians did not expect her to recover, she has come a long way.

         The process of building a reconstructed self requires an individual to let go of the past and look to the future. According to the Chaos Theory of Adjusting to Life Transitions (Bussolair & Goodell, 2009), when a major life change occurs, the initial stress reaction is to return to the safety of the past.  As an individual realizes that is no longer possible, he/she either adapts to change or gets “stuck.”  As she/he adjusts new possibilities emerge, and as these opportunities are explored, a new reconstructed self emerges. While the initial reaction of all the women was the desire to return to life as it was, they realized that, while you cannot return to the past, life offers new opportunities to those with the courage to “seize the day.”

         America has been slow to recognize the contributions of women to the combat efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan.  Sarah stated that she was often overlooked when she attended veteran events: Americans thanked the male veterans she was standing with, but did not recognize her as a wounded warrior unless she mentioned it.  By sharing their stories of personal courage and adaptation to traumatic amputation, these women are paving the way for a better understanding of how female wounded warriors adapt to traumatic injury.         

Chart 1.  Summarization of Demographic Data on Six Servicewomen with Traumatic Amputations

Name

Jessica

Sarah

Christine

Nicole

Amy

Lisa

Age in

2010

24

30

42

24

30

25

Military Training

Army National Guard - Logistics

West Point

Army ROTC

College

Army Military Police

Army ROTC

College

Army Explosive

Ordnance

Disposal

Military job

Logistics/Road repair

Gunner

Commander MP Platoon

Helicopter pilot/battle captain

Military Police

Gunner

Convoy Platoon Commander

EOD Technician

Current/Last Rank 

Sergeant

Captain

Major

Specialist

2nd Lieutenant

Sergeant

Cause of amputation

Motorcycle crash

Rocket Propelled Grenade

Rocket Propelled Grenade

Improvised Explosive

Device

Improvised Explosive

Device

Improvised Explosive

Device

Amputation

Below the knee

Right arm Disarticulation

Below the Knee (BK), Above the knee (AK)

Double Below the knee

Above the knee

Both arms above the elbow

Prosthetics

Walking & running legs

Cosmetic arm

C- Leg and walking leg

Volunteer to help future Wounded Women Warriors.....

<!-- /* Font Definitions */ @font-face {font-family:Times; panose-1:2 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0; mso-font-charset:0; mso-generic-font-family:auto; mso-font-pitch:variable; mso-font-signature:3 0 0 0 1 0;} @font-face {font-family:Verdana; panose-1:2 11 6 4 3 5 4 4 2 4; mso-font-charset:0; mso-generic-font-family:auto; mso-font-pitch:variable; mso-font-signature:3 0 0 0 1 0;} @font-face {font-family:Cambria; panose-1:2 4 5 3 5 4 6 3 2 4; mso-font-charset:0; mso-generic-font-family:auto; mso-font-pitch:variable; mso-font-signature:3 0 0 0 1 0;} /* Style Definitions */ p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal {mso-style-parent:""; margin:0in; margin-bottom:.0001pt; mso-pagination:widow-orphan; font-size:11.0pt; mso-bidi-font-size:12.0pt; font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-ascii-font-family:Verdana; mso-fareast-font-family:Cambria; mso-fareast-theme-font:minor-latin; mso-hansi-font-family:Verdana; mso-bidi-font-family:"Times New Roman"; mso-bidi-theme-font:minor-bidi;} @page Section1 {size:8.5in 11.0in; margin:1.0in 1.0in 1.0in 1.0in; mso-header-margin:.5in; mso-footer-margin:.5in; mso-paper-source:0;} div.Section1 {page:Section1;} -->

My study seeks to understand the adjustment issues faced by American women warriors who experience a traumatic amputation.   In order to provide a maximally supportive environment for these women during their recovery, it is crucial to understand what it is like to live in their world.


At the present time there is no published research.  As the number of women warriors returning with physical disabilities increases, it is vital that medical and mental health support staff understand the unique challenges these women face.  This information may also help their friends and families understand their needs so they can provide the support these women need to make a successful return to self-sufficiency in life and work.

Over 220,000 female soldiers have been deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan for one or more tours of duty.  As of August 2009, a total of 121 women warriors have died, and it is estimated over 620 have received serious injuries.  It is very important to learn about their life experience.

This study will use internet interviews using Skype to understand this life experience. Each woman will be invited to tell her story of how she adjusted to life as an amputee with the assurance of confidentiality. She will also know that her gift of sharing will be used to help future women warriors through their adjustment process.

The research questions are: "Please tell me about your experience of combat as a woman."  "How has being injured changed your life?"  "What is your daily life like today?"

                Transcripts of the individual interviews will be analyzed for common threads and then the co-participants would be asked to participate in a Skype focus group to discuss the findings.  Using the common threads reported in this study, a tapestry for understanding this life phenomenon can be woven. This study will be conducted in fulfillment of the requirements for the doctoral degree from the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville.

 

 

Institutional Review Board Information

Title-    A Phenomenological Study of Female Service Members Adjustment to Traumatic Amputation

 

Researchers/ Investigators

 

Janet Cater

Graduate Student

College of Education and Health Professions

Graduate Education Building

University of Arkansas

Fayetteville, AR   72701

479- 575-5326

 

 

Faculty Advisor:

Richard Roessler, Ph.D.

Rehabilitation Education

153 Graduate Education Building

University of Arkansas

Fayetteville, Arkansas 72701

Phone: (479) 575-6414 

Administrator:

Iroshi Windwalker

Office of Research Support and Sponsored Programs
120 Ozark Hall
1 University of Arkansas
Fayetteville, AR 72701

Phone: (479)575-3845

 I am seeking to understand the psychosocial adjustment issues experienced by women veterans who have had a traumatic amputation. I am interested in your life experience.

 

The information you share with me will expand our knowledge of the life adjustment issues women experience after a traumatic amputation. The results could significantly enhance our understanding of this process. Quotations from you may be used in the reporting of my research, but they will be stripped of identifying information to protect your confidentiality. I will not link your name to anything you say in the text of my dissertation or any other publications or presentations.

 

The interviews will take about 90 minutes of your time which can be completed in 30 minute intervals.  In addition, as a co-researcher you will be asked to review my summary of your story and will have the opportunity to participate in a focus group with other women veterans at a later time.  You will also have the opportunity to review my transcript of your narratives and to comment on the finished study.

 

Participation is voluntary.  You can, of course, decline to discuss any issue, answer any question, etc. as well as to stop participating at any time. If responding to the interview questions results in any emotional distress, you may contact your local Vet Center or contact me and I will find the closest Vet Center to you.

 

If you have any additional questions concerning this research or your participation in it, please feel free to contact me, my dissertation supervisor or our university research office. 


I would like to make a tape recording of our conversation, so that I can have an accurate record of the information that you provide to me.  I will transcribe that recording, but your name will not be attached to the transcripts. I will only attach a code number to the transcript, and names of participants and corresponding identification numbers will be kept in a locked safe. Transcripts will be kept confidential and securely in my possession.  The tapes will be erased after this research project is complete."

About

I received my Ph.D. from the University of Arkansas researching the life experience of women warriors who experience a traumatic amputation.